The Power of Point of View

(quarter)YEAR in REVIEW. . .and a look ahead to a New Year of Perspective Criticism – GARY YAMASAKI

This blog was launched three months ago, and from the beginning, it has been intended as a site for the collective development of biblical scholarship. Specifically, it exists as a venue for dialogue on the interpretive significance of the point-of-view crafting in biblical narratives. So, week after week, ideas on this topic have been posted to the site to generate discussion on this topic.

The first month was quiet in this regard. However, things started percolating at the beginning of the second month. A post exploring how attention to point of view might impact live performances of biblical passages (Nov 1/12) prompted a response by biblical storyteller Leon Seaman laying out how insights on the significance of point of view in biblical narratives influence his performance of the Gospel of Mark (Nov 6/12). And this was the start of an exchange that ended up drawing in four participants, stretching through the month of December (Dec 5/12, Dec 12/12, Dec 13/12, Dec 20/12, Dec 21/12); a new blog category entitled “point of view and Performance Criticism” was create to accommodate this discourse.

Another exchange has been developing around a key suggestion in the development of point-of-view theory to this point: point-of-view crafting being able to produce “empathy” for characters. This is an idea that was introduced in one of the earliest posts (Sep 25/12), and a post addressing its significance in the John 20 account of Mary at the tomb (Nov 22/12) drew a challenge from Robert Tannehill (Dec 6/12). This challenge focuses mainly on the way the John 20 analysis treats the informational plane of point of view (introduced in the Oct 25/2012 post, and illustrated in a look at “Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid” in the Nov 29/2012 post). The questions Tannehill raises make clear that more work needs to be done on the empathy aspect of point-of-view crafting.

The spatial plane (Oct 4/2012) and the psychological plane (Nov 15/2012) of point of view have also been introduced, but there are still three other planes that have not yet been covered, the most prominent being the temporal plane. This is a topic that will be addressed early in the new year.

Film has been a significant component of the blog, as reflected in the numerous posts containing descriptions of movie scenes serving as illustrations in discussions of point-of-view dynamics operating in biblical narratives, and there is even a blog category completely dedicated to “point of view on Screen”. It should be noted that these treatments of movie scenes have been based only on a literary understanding of point of view applied to the genre of film, as opposed to an understanding of point of view coming out of film studies. However, Laura Copier, Assistant Professor of Media Studies at University of Amsterdam, will be addressing this deficiency by contributing insights on point of view from her work on film.

Another point of critique of this site’s treatment of point of view in biblical narrative is its strong continuity to the state of point-of-view theory as it stood back in the 1970s and 1980s, when the concept of point of view first came to the attention of biblical scholars. However, this literary concept has continued to develop in the intervening decades, calling for exploration of these more recent discussions to see if they shed any light on new ways in which point-of-view crafting might be significant to the interpretation of biblical narratives, and Janice Capel Anderson will be providing a look into this recent narratology.

Besides Copier and Anderson, there are a number of other scholars slated to contribute blog posts in the coming weeks—the Perspective Criticism community continues to grow. If you are interested in joining the discourse, use the “Contact” page to send post ideas to the site administrator.


Tagged as: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.